Beyond The Data: The Psychology Of Fundraising

/

Author —Auteur — Michelle Bell

Make no mistake. We love data. We trust data. We believe in data…. But we also believe in the power of human emotions. 

Data has become so powerful in mapping and predicting human behaviour, we often lose touch with the hearts and minds driving the behaviour. So, let’s look at both – what does the data tell us about donor behaviour and what is the soft side of what is driving that behaviour.

Empathy vs. Sympathy

Donors must be able to relate your mission and your ask. However, if you ask them to put themselves in the victim’s shoes, it causes distress and they can clam up. Rather, ask for sympathy – to imagine how the victim feels. This is a richer, and safer place to start.

One vs. Many

While some people are influenced by the statistical view of a situation, most are influenced by the closeness and vividness of the suffering of those in need. Known as the “identifiable victim effect” people often prefer to help a single identifiable victim rather than the masses. Know when to balance the stats that demonstrate the magnitude of your mission, with the individual stories about the impact you have on the ground.

The Time-Ask Effect

The world works on more than monetary currencies. In the charitable sector, it is common for an ask to be for time in the form of volunteering, or money in the form of financial donations. People inherently put different values on time and money, and if you are asking for both, the order in which you ask can have an impact on how much is given if at all. When asked for money first and time second, people react more analytically and conservatively. When asked for time first, and money second, people start from a place of personal experience and react through emotion. This latter path is more likely to lead to a donation and larger amounts.

Similarity

As much as we all want to believe that our human nature drives us to give to all equally without bias, the science of psychology tells us otherwise. Studies using Minimal Group Paradigm methodology have demonstrated that people show favouritism for people for their own “in-group”. At face-value this statement can conjure up unsavoury images of distrimination and favouritism. Rest assured that similarities can be found beyond the traditional go-tos – similarity is established when a donor can see aspects of their own self in the recipient or can see a clear path on how they could become like the person in need.

Don’t Oversell the Problem

When communications focus on the size of a problem, donors can shut down due to an instinct to save the greatest portion of people Vs. the greatest number of people. This means that rather than save 10 out of 1000 people from cancer, the majority of people would rather use the same or even more resources to save 9 out of 10 people from heart disease.

Manage the Bucket

Similarly, people can be reluctant to give when a problem seems too big to make any tangible, noticeable difference. Known as the “drop in a bucket” effect charities need to ensure that donors know that their contributions will have an impact.

Numbed by Numbers

Again, a cautionary tale to avoid overestimating the problem, or focusing too much on the numbers…humans have a tendency to neglect the scope of the problem when dealing with social issues. This is called scope insensitivity. People do not scale up their efforts in proportion to a problem’s true size. For example, a donor willing to give $200 to help one person might only be willing to give $100 to help 100 people, instead of the proportional amount.

Power of Peer Pressure

Psychologists already know that people rely on cues from others to make decisions. The playground and our high school years are a testament to this. Recent studies have revealed that social information can lead to higher donations when used properly. While you certainly want to welcome donations of any size, and you want to ensure that you don’t alienate or scare away any potential donors, research indicates that a suggested giving level in the 90th-95th percentile can lead to larger donations. When choosing online suggested giving levels, have an option near your average donation size but be sure to present more generous options.

Coveting the Winning Team

We must admit, while there is romance in fighting for the underdog there is something great about being on the winning team. Fundraising progress bars (a.k.a. The thermometer) can be a great way to show your fundraising campaign’s progress, but it also helps you motivate people to give. While this unfortunately means that you may be in for some tough slugging at the beginning of your campaign, the good news is that the closer you get to your goal, the more willing people will be to give. Why? People tend to feel a greater sense of accomplishment when they contribute at the end of a winning effort than when they contribute early on. We all remember the joy and excitement of the winning goal

Fundraising is a human to human initiative. Mind the data, but don’t forget to embrace and leverage the power of human emotions. Integrating these insights into your messaging can get your campaigns from good to great. Want to learn more? We can help. Let’s do this.

Michelle Bell

Directeur général du marketing

Michelle a plus de 18 ans d’expérience dans le domaine du marketing et des opérations. Elle a travaillé en gestion traditionnelle de la marque pour des entreprises mondiales de produits de consommation courante. En outre, elle a œuvré en marketing et en stratégie commerciale pour le secteur public, notamment pour Monnaie royale canadienne à l’occasion de son Canada 150.

Plus de réflexions

.

Mode de vie
I am the master of my fate, I am the captain of my...
Bien-être
Dans son livre Good to Great, Jim Collins raconte l’histoire de James Stockdale,...
Mode de vie
Les plus grandes bénédictions de la vie se présentent parfois dans les plus...

Rob Hyams

Directeur de la création

Rob a construit des marques et des campagnes depuis qu’il est venu au monde… ou du moins c’est ce que l’on ressent. Il a un don rare; une capacité à distiller le complexe dans une histoire succincte et convaincante.

Brent Martel

Stratégie de site web

Brent est notre expert résident dans la création de sites Web qui convertissent et simplifient votre technologie marketing pour qu’elle fonctionne pour vous. Ça sonne bien, non?

Alan Horic

Stratégie numérique

Alan sait tout (sans blague) lorsqu’il s’agit de déployer votre stratégie de marketing numérique; de la recherche à l’affichage en passant par le marketing basé sur les comptes, il peut transformer vos annonces en une machine génératrice de revenus.

Francesca Désulmé

Gestionnaire de comptes

Artiste, passionnée du monde des communications et défenseuse des enjeux sociaux, la force de Francesca repose dans l’ensemble de ses expériences. Elle saura mener vos projets à terme grâce à son enthousiasme, sa créativité et son sens de l’organisation.

Peter Georgariou

Fondateur et directeur général

Adepte de Bouddha, passionné de diététique, Peter aime participer à des épreuves d’Ironman et de marathon pendant son temps libre. À chaque instant, Peter est un homme de cœur qui sait poser les bonnes questions. Faites-nous confiance…

Bárbara d’Oro

Stratège de contenu

Barbara est une journaliste de profession qui adore parler aux gens, poser de bonnes questions et donner une voix à leurs histoires. Étant brésilienne, elle ne dira jamais non à une sortie BBQ à une churrascaria du coin.

Michelle Bell

Directrice marketing

Michelle possède une nature attentionnée et une personnalité adorablement intello en plus d’une triple compétence dans les domaines créatif, stratégique et de l’ingénierie : la recette parfaite pour aider votre organisation à atteindre de nouveaux sommets, quoi!

Karen Bramhill

Directrice de l'expérience client

Artiste, épidémiologiste, spécialiste des opérations et véritable amoureuse de la vie; Karen est un véritable génie universel qui apporte une richesse d’attention et de connaissances à chacune des choses qu’elle entreprend. Sachez seulement que l’ambiguïté et elle ne font pas bon ménage. And for the record, ambiguity and her are not the best of friends.

Jennifer
Lim-Tamkican

Conception graphique et créativité

Ayant touché à tout en tant que pigiste marketing, Jennifer travaille de façon très réfléchie et pratique pour ses créations. Elle est la combinaison parfaite de créativité et style, que ce soit dans l’art ou dans la vie.

Geneviève
Côté-Nault

Gestionnaire de comptes

Gen apporte l’énergie pour lancer votre projet et la détermination pour le mener à terme. De sa conscience émergeront votre meilleure stratégie et quelques solutions pour sauver la planète.

Jenna Araujo

Directrice artistique et conceptuelle

Jenna a une créativité aussi polyvalente qu’une boîte à outils… tout ça, avec un sourire! Elle a une solution design pour tout problème; en plus d’avoir le rire le plus contagieux du milieu.